Home
Tolkien News
Biography
Books
The Hobbit
Lord of the Rings
The Silmarillion
Children of Hurin
Unfinished Tales
Hist of Middle-earth
Sigurd & Gudrun
Hist of The Hobbit
LotR Movies
The Hobbit Movie
Hunt for Gollum
Middle-earth
The Inklings
Suggested Reading
Tolkien Scholarship
Tolkien Posters
Tolkien Blog
Resources
Contact Me
Link To Me
Search this Site
Disclaimer & Privacy
Subscribe To This Site
XML RSS
Add to Google
Add to My Yahoo!
Add to My MSN
Subscribe with Bloglines
 

An Argument for Bombadil as Valar

by B. Edward Cave
(Nottingham)

I think this article fails to give adequate credence to the Vala hypothesis. Gene Hargrove's excellent article makes a very convincing case for his Valaric potential.

It is also important to note that Tolkien does not say that Sauron would be able to conquer Bombadil as Valar. This is a common misunderstanding caused by the somewhat hazy definition of the 'avatar' like embodiment which Valar and Maiar take on. If Bombadil were to fall as Gandalf hypothesizes (although being a mere Ishtar he does not have the ability to say so definitively), it would only be from his physical embodiment at which time he would return to the utmost west. More important is Tolkien's re-definition of that statement in Letters 179 where he says "there would be nothing left for him in the world of Sauron".

I agree with Hargrove and conclude against this article.

Bombadil fits perfectly the role of Aule the Smith (and Goldberry Yavanna) and Tolkien's concern for his anthropological meaning (Letters 192) only serves to re-enforce that reading. A final thought is that the reason Bombadil appears so un-Valaric is because he has taken a 'vow of poverty' (Letters 179) which fits in well with Aule's nature and recalls the self-limitation displayed in passages like Philippians 2:6 of Christ's descent (which the devout Tolkien would have undoubtedly been familiar with). Not that this is to say Bombadil is God or Iluvatar but the principal of self-elected boundaries (as discussed by Hargrove) applies admirably.

Click here to read or post comments.

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How?
Simply click here to return to Tom Bombadil
.


footer for Tolkien page